Screening or Diagnostic Test?
Screening tests are not diagnostic tests. The primary purpose of screening tests is to detect early/asymptomatic disease in large numbers of apparently healthy individuals in at risk areas. The purpose of a diagnostic test is to establish the presence (or absence) of disease as a basis for treatment decisions in symptomatic or screen positive individuals (confirmatory test).
|
Screening Tests |
Diagnostic Tests |
Purpose |
To detect potential disease indicators. |
To establish presence/absence of disease. |
Target Population |
Large numbers of asymptomatic, but potentially ‘at risk’ individuals. |
Symptomatic patients to establish diagnosis, or asymptomatic individuals with a positive screening test. |
Test Method |
Simple, acceptable to patients and staff. |
Maybe invasive, expensive but justifiable as necessary to establish diagnosis. |
Positive Result Threshold |
Generally chose towards high sensitivity not to miss potential disease. |
Chosen towards high specificity (true negatives). More weight given to accuracy and precision than to patient acceptability. |
Positive Result |
Essentially indicates suspicion of disease (often used in combination with other risk factors) that warrants confirmation. |
Result provides a definite diagnosis. |
Cost |
Cheap, benefits should justify the costs since large numbers of patients will need to be screened to identify a small number of potential cases. |
Higher costs associated with diagnostic test maybe justified to establish diagnosis. |
Follow us: